Top 5 Roofing Materials: Durability, Value & Storm Protection

Your roof is your home’s first line of defense — especially here in Indiana, where storms, hail, and heavy winds can do serious damage. Here’s my ranking of the Top 5 roofing materials, including a score of how they hold up in a storm.

1. Metal Roof

Storm Score: 95/100
Metal roofing leads the pack for storm protection. It resists wind, hail, and fire, and sheds snow with ease. Lifespan runs 40–70 years, and some carriers offer discounts for metal roofs due to their durability.

2. Impact-Resistant (IR) Shingles

Storm Score: 90/100
Specifically designed to handle hail and debris impacts, IR shingles are a nice upgrade from standard asphalt. 25–30 year lifespan and possible insurance discounts make this a smart, storm-ready choice.

3. Architectural Asphalt Shingles

Storm Score: 80/100
A big step up from basic shingles, architectural asphalt offers better wind and impact resistance at a reasonable price. Expect 20–30 years of solid protection with attractive design options.

4. Composite (Synthetic) Shingles

Storm Score: 85/100
Made from advanced materials that mimic wood or slate, composite shingles balance good looks with serious durability. 30–50 year lifespan, excellent impact resistance, and lightweight installation.

5. Slate Roofing

Storm Score: 95/100
The heavyweight champion of roofing, natural slate shrugs off storms, fire, and pests. 75–100+ year lifespan, though installation is pricey and heavy. If you want the “forever roof,” this is it.

Indiana weather is no joke — and your roof is one place where a smart investment can save you thousands down the road.

Thinking about a roof upgrade? Let’s talk. We’re happy to answer questions and check if your material qualifies you for insurance savings! We may even be able to refer you to a good roofer in your neighborhood. Call or Text us at 317-758-5828 or send an email to info@bragginsurance.com